FIRST AMENDMENT FREEDOM FORUM.ORG
Newseum First Amendment Newsroom Diversity
spacer
spacer
First Amendment Center
First Amendment Text
Columnists
Research Packages
First Amendment Publications

spacer
Today's News
Related links
Contact Us



spacer
spacer graphic

Senator considers resurrecting legislation to regulate election reporting

By The Associated Press

11.27.00

Printer-friendly page

Sen. Ted Stevens, R-Alaska, right, watches TV election returns on Nov. 7 in Anchorage.

WASHINGTON — Sen. Ted Stevens is considering resurrecting a couple of election ideas after reviewing the Nov. 7 election.

Stevens, R-Alaska, says he believes televised election reports from the East Coast affected voting in Western states. He says he would like to see uniform polling place hours nationwide and that he wants television stations prohibited from broadcasting information about exit polls.

Stevens said he came up with a similar proposal that passed in the Senate in the 1970s but died in the House.

Stevens says he understands that limiting the media could raise difficult free-speech issues.

"It's a very touchy thing," he said.

The senator said the Federal Communications Commission could ban exit poll reporting as a condition of obtaining a federal license to broadcast television signals on a particular frequency.

"It's not regulating them, it's conditioning them," Stevens said.

Both Stevens and Sen. Frank Murkowski, R-Alaska, said the exit poll reports were discussed at a Republican strategy meeting in Florida last weekend.

Stevens also said the Internet, which didn't exist when he made his last proposal, would be harder to control because the FCC has no control over who uses it. "I do not think we could condition the Internet releases," he said.

Stevens says something needs to be done about televised exit poll projections, which he says "influence elections." He cites the broadcast networks bungling of their calls of the presidential race in Florida, where both George W. Bush and Al Gore were declared the winner at various times on election night.

He believes that some Republicans, hearing the networks' incorrect projections that Bush had lost Florida, may have decided not to vote because they thought Gore's election was a foregone conclusion.

"Our people just didn't go to vote," Stevens said. "In California, some of the people who were calling to get out the vote just went home."

Meanwhile, Walter Cronkite has a suggestion for news organizations trying to call election night winners: Slow down.

"I don't understand the need for this speed, although I was certainly one of the progenitors of the whole idea of the exit polling," Cronkite said in an interview in yesterday's Charleston, W.Va., Gazette-Mail.

"Nowadays, with the exit polling, we're calling these states so early that there are really some three hours left of voting time out on the West Coast, and it seems to me that very probably it could work just as well to withhold returns until all the states have voted," the retired CBS anchorman said.

The electoral mayhem in Florida "kind of casts all of our thinking a little differently than it had been up to this election," he added.

Related

Law firm asks FCC to investigate early election calls
Attorneys contend networks subverted public interest with their efforts to win the race to project next U.S. president.  12.01.00

Oklahoma lawmaker proposes presidential election-return blackout
Legislation would bar state election officials from reporting vote results for 2 ½ hours, restrict exit polling.  11.14.00

Group with GOP ties sues TV networks over early call on Florida
Lawsuit filed in Okaloosa County seeks to prevent networks, Voter News Service from making similar projections in future elections before all polls close in a state.  11.16.00

Congressional Republicans charge networks with election-night bias
House Telecommunications Subcommittee chairman says early calls for Gore might have discouraged Republican voters, affected outcome in Florida and other states.  11.17.00

Networks should shun congressional hearings on election coverage
By Douglas Lee Voluntary participation by media in hearings would legitimize an illegitimate inquiry.  11.22.00

Florida election returns prove Achilles' heel for news media
Networks, newspapers backpedal after prematurely declaring George W. Bush winner of 2000 presidential race.  11.08.00

Newseum highlights media's history of election blunders
'These kinds of mistakes have always been made,' says news historian Eric Newton.  11.09.00

House panel to review news media's election calls
Rep. Billy Tauzin said early call of Florida for Al Gore may have deterred voters in Western states from going to the polls.  11.10.00

graphic
spacer