University won't punish fraternity members in 'blackface' incident

By The Associated Press

11.29.02

Printer-friendly page

KNOXVILLE, Tenn. — The University of Tennessee will not penalize six white fraternity members accused in a "blackface" incident, saying the right of expression must be protected even "when some find it to be insensitive and offensive."

Black students saw members of the Kappa Sigma fraternity with painted faces walking to an off-campus bar for a private party Oct. 22.

Confronted, the Kappa Sigma members reportedly said they were trying to look like the Jackson 5 or Louis Armstrong, were going to be in an "air guitar" contest or were members of a black fraternity. Complaints prompted the university to launch an investigation the next day.

This month, in a Web posting and an ad in the student newspaper, the university denounced the incident but said it would not punish the students or the fraternity. It said in a statement that the students' First Amendment rights limited the school's ability to punish them.

"The University of Tennessee is firmly committed to protecting the constitutional rights of freedom of speech and expression — even when some find it to be insensitive and offensive," the statement said.

The position came as a surprise, especially since Kappa Sigma's national organization had suspended Tennessee's campus chapter and apologized.

But the university's statement emphasized that the incident should not be seen as an innocent college prank.

"To African-Americans, blackface recalls old time minstrel shows that depicted African-Americans as ignorant simpletons — mere human scenery. Blackface resurrects latent stereotypes and undermines progress."

The 25,500-student university is about 7% black.

The statement said the school would work to enhance programs on cultural diversity and ethnic sensitivity and increase funding to African and African-American studies.

But it added: "In all honesty, the university cannot guarantee that similar incidents will not occur."

In the past year, Auburn University, Oklahoma State University and most recently the University of Virginia all have experienced fraternity blackface incidents.

Related

Universities struggle with free speech, hate speech
Some argue that hate speech is protected; others say schools are right to punish such speech when intolerance threatens students and their ability to learn.  04.28.02

Students object to 'hate radio,' ask school to end affiliation with station
University of Oregon can't use its contract to dictate program content without risk of violating the First Amendment, says administrator.  12.16.02

Alabama college ordered to reinstate suspended fraternity members
Lawsuit claims Auburn University violated students' speech, association rights by punishing them for wearing blackface at Halloween party.  11.26.01