NYC: Sept. 11 records shouldn't be released

By The Associated Press

07.23.02

Printer-friendly page

NEW YORK — Many records of the fire department's response to the World Trade Center attack should not be made public, the Bloomberg administration has asserted.

The New York Times reported today that city officials, responding to the newspaper's lawsuit for access to the records, cite victims' privacy and the federal prosecution of terror suspect Zacarias Moussaoui as reasons to keep them secret.

The Times' lawsuit in state Supreme Court in Manhattan asks for the release of audiotapes of dispatchers' and firefighters' communications, and a department collection of firefighters' accounts of the attack.

The city says that an order from the Virginia court where Moussaoui is charged bars them from releasing the documents.

The administration also argues that releasing the records would invade the privacy of firefighters and the families of those killed on Sept. 11.

The Times has disputed those claims and has said the records would be of enormous historical value.

Update

Judge orders NYC to release Sept. 11 records
State court grants New York Times request for access to hundreds of documents, 911 tapes, but says city can keep some material secret.  02.06.03

Related

USA TODAY seeks cockpit recordings in Moussaoui case
Federal judge says newspaper's request is premature because she hasn't decided whether to allow the government to use the tapes.  08.21.02

Moussaoui's diatribes will no longer be made public
Accused Sept. 11 conspirator has been using court as mouthpiece by filing motions filled with 'irrelevant, inflammatory and insulting' language, judge rules.  09.06.02