Newseum First Amendment Newsroom Diversity
First Amendment Center
First Amendment Text
Research Packages
First Amendment Publications

Today's News
Related links
Contact Us

spacer graphic

Magazine reporter found in contempt for talking to juror

By The Associated Press


Printer-friendly page

CAMDEN, N.J. — A magazine reporter was found in contempt of court yesterday for violating a judge's order that barred the news media from talking to jurors in the murder trial of a rabbi.

Carol Saline, a staff writer at Philadelphia Magazine, could be sentenced to six months in jail and fined $1,000 for intentionally approaching a juror on Nov. 9 and asking him questions, Superior Court Judge Theodore Z. Davis said. No sentencing date was scheduled.

Saline did not speak during the hearing before Davis and would not comment afterward.

Saline's lawyer argued that she acted inadvertently.

Davis' ruling sets the stage for hearings next month for four Philadelphia Inquirer reporters also accused of violating Superior Court Judge Linda G. Baxter's order during the trial of Rabbi Fred J. Neulander.

The rabbi is accused of arranging the killing of his wife, Carol, in 1994. Baxter declared a mistrial on Nov. 13 after jurors said they could not agree on a verdict despite more than 40 hours of deliberations.

Neulander will face a retrial. His lawyers are attempting to have capital murder charges dismissed to avoid a possible death sentence.

The incident involving Saline happened a day after the jury first indicated it might be deadlocked.

One juror told the judge Saline approached him outside the courthouse and asked if he or other jurors would submit to interviews after the case was over.

"She was willing to take the shot because I guess getting the story is a little more important than the orderly judicial process of determining the guilt or innocence of the person," Davis said.

However, Loren Feldman, editor of Philadelphia Magazine, said Saline was not writing about the trial.

"No one can have any doubt about her intentions," Feldman said.

Baxter's order against talking to jurors also prohibited publishing jurors' names or likenesses or contacting them even after the trial. The judge cited the possible effect of publicity on potential jurors in the second trial.

The Inquirer reporters are accused of violating the order by publishing a juror's name. They are scheduled to appear in court Feb. 25.

The Inquirer's publisher, Philadelphia Newspapers Inc., has appealed parts of the order itself.


Reporter fined for approaching juror in murder trial
Meanwhile, New Jersey high court agrees to hear appeal of order that barred journalists from contacting jury in case against rabbi.  02.08.02


Reporters charged with contempt for printing juror's name
Four Philadelphia Inquirer journalists could face up to six months in jail, $1,000 fines if found guilty of violating order barring media contact with jurors.  12.07.01


Reporter does not have to turn over notes, judge rules
Court rebuffs efforts by N.J. rabbi accused of arranging wife's murder to attain records from Philadelphia Inquirer journalist.  09.12.00

When judges act as editors, public loses out
By Douglas Lee 2001 closes with three disparate decisions by trial judges with seemingly common goal of blocking public's right to know.  01.01.02