FIRST AMENDMENT FREEDOM FORUM.ORG
Newseum First Amendment Newsroom Diversity
spacer
spacer
First Amendment Center
First Amendment Text
Columnists
Research Packages
First Amendment Publications

spacer
Today's News
Related links
Contact Us



spacer
spacer graphic

Federal appeals court again upholds graduation prayer

By The Associated Press

05.15.01

Printer-friendly page

ATLANTA — The 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has again ruled that public school students in Florida's Duval County may choose a class member to give a prayer or other personal message at high school graduations.

The appeals court on May 11 voted 8-4 that such statements do not violate the constitutional doctrine of church-state separation as long as certain rules are observed.

The appellate court made the same decision in March 2000 in Adler v. Duval County, but the U.S. Supreme Court ordered it to take another look in light of the justices' decision last June in Santa Fe Independent School District v. Doe striking down student-led prayers at football games in Texas.

The appellate court concluded there were some key distinctions between the two cases.

"First, we emphasize that under Duval County's policy, school officials have no power to direct that a message (let alone a religious message) be delivered at graduation ceremonies, or control in any way the content of any message actually to be delivered," wrote Judge Stanley Marcus for the majority.

The policy leaves the contents of the message up to the student selected to deliver it. A graduating class also has the option of deciding not to have such a message or whether such a message is delivered at the opening of graduation, the closing or both.

School officials are forbidden from monitoring or reviewing the statements, which are limited to two minutes maximum.

The Atlanta-based court also rejected the argument that student statements were transformed into state-sponsored speech because they were delivered at a school-sponsored event.

Marcus quoted from last year's opinion: "While schools may make private religious speech their own by endorsing it, schools do not endorse all speech they do not censor."

Ruling the policy unconstitutional, the court continued, would be impossible "without effectively banning all religious speech at school graduations, no matter how private the message or how divorced the message may be from any state review, let alone censorship."

The appellate court's new decision, however, may not be the last one in the case because it could be appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court.

The dissenting judges cited the high court's ruling in the Texas case, which found that the mere passage of such a policy "has the purpose and perception of governmental establishment of religion."

Invocations and benedictions were allowed in Jacksonville public school graduations until the 1992 Supreme Court ruling in Lee v. Weisman prohibiting clergy-led prayers at public school graduations.

In 1993, Duval County school officials adopted a new policy that let high school seniors decide whether to choose a fellow student to give a "brief opening and/or closing message" at graduation.

Update

Supreme Court won't weigh in on graduation prayer
Group had sued to block Duval County, Fla., policy allowing senior class to choose student 'chaplains' to give inspirational addresses at high school commencements.  12.10.01

Previous

Federal appeals court upholds Florida district's graduation-prayer policy
State does not sponsor or endorse prayer when it's approved by a majority of students, judges find.  03.16.00

Related

Federal officials reverse position on religious-based grant program
White House concludes agency’s exclusion of secular groups violates spirit of Bush administration’s ‘faith-based initiative.’  05.18.01

Federal court bars student-led prayer at Illinois graduation
District officials defend 80-year tradition, saying students, not administrators, plan ceremony, but judge says high school ‘can’t license students to do what it cannot do.’  05.18.01

State lawmakers consider school-prayer proposals
Florida House passes bill allowing student-led prayer at nonrequired assemblies; South Carolina legislators seek legal opinion on 'moment of silent prayer.'  10.25.01

graphic
spacer